Skip to Content

Which is better hernia surgery open or laparoscopic surgery?

The decision as to which type of hernia surgery is better depends on a few different factors and ultimately should come down to a discussion between the individual and their doctor. While both forms of surgery can effectively treat the underlying cause of the hernia, there are some differences to consider.

Open surgery, also known as the open hernia repair, involves making a single, large incision in the abdominal area and is generally used to treat larger hernias. Laparoscopic surgery involves making several small incisions and uses a thin tool known as a laparoscope (which has a mini camera attached to it) to perform the surgery.

The main advantage of laparoscopic hernia surgery is improved patient outcomes, as it requires less time for recovery, less discomfort and a smaller scar. It may also provide some additional benefits such as less risk of infection and a lower risk of hernia recurrence.

On the other hand, open surgery may have a slightly higher success rate when treating some types of hernias and may provide a better view of the operative site for surgeons. It may also be the only option for some individuals depending on the size and location of the hernia.

Ultimately, any decision should be decided by a discussion between the individual and their physician/surgeon as they can take into consideration all the factors and come up with the best solution tailored to the individual’s specific circumstances.

What is the procedure for hernia surgery?

Hernia surgery is a procedure that is used to repair a weakened area in the wall of the abdomen where a hernia has formed. There are a few different types of hernia repair surgeries and the procedure chosen typically depends on the type of hernia and the doctor’s preference.

Generally, hernia surgery involves the following steps:

• Anesthesia: An anesthesiologist will first administer an anesthetic to ensure the patient is comfortable and not in any pain during the procedure.

• Making an Incision: The surgeon will make a small incision in the hernia site. The surgeon may use scissor action or a special device called a stapler to sever any tissue that may be blocking the area.

• Hernia Repair: The surgeon will then repair the wall of the abdomen by placing a mesh material over the hernia. This mesh reinforces the weakened area in the abdominal wall, preventing the hernia from recurring.

• Closing the Incision: The surgeon will then close the incision with absorbable sutures. A dressing or bandage may be applied to the hernia site to help protect the area from infection.

• Post-surgery Care: After the surgery, the patient will likely need to stay in the hospital overnight for observation. Following the procedure, there may be some pain and/or discomfort and medication may be prescribed as needed.

It is important to follow your doctor’s instructions for post-surgery care, including any dietary and activity restrictions.

Following hernia surgery, recovery typically takes between one to four weeks, although this can vary depending on the type of hernia and the person’s individual healing process. The majority of people make a full recovery and experience little to no post-surgery problems.

However, it is important to pay attention to any potential signs of infection or other complications, and to contact your doctor if any issues arise.

Is hernia surgery a major surgery?

Hernia surgery can be considered a major surgery, depending on the type of hernia and how complex it is. Some hernias may require a simple procedure that can be done in an outpatient setting, while others may require open or laparoscopic abdominal surgery.

Typically, hernia surgery involves the repair of a weakened area in the abdominal wall that is allowing organs or fatty tissue to push through. This could involve repairing the hole in the abdominal wall with sutures or a surgical mesh, and then returning any protruding organs or fatty tissue back in place.

Because hernia surgery is performed to restore the body to its normal functioning state, the complexity of the procedure will ultimately be determined by the individual’s unique needs, and therefore, it may be classified as major or minor surgery.

How long does it take to recover from a hernia operation?

The amount of time it takes to recover from a hernia operation varies from person to person and can depend on factors such as the type of surgery and how extensive the repair was. Generally, you can expect to return to work and other activities about two to three weeks after laparoscopic hernia surgery.

Most people are able to return to full activity levels by around four to six weeks after the procedure. However, it is important to follow your surgeon’s instructions for post-operative care and allow your body enough time to heal.

Depending on how much of a strain the hernia exerts on the surrounding muscles and organs, some people may need more time to regain full strength and performance in the area. Additionally, if you have a heavy workload or very active lifestyle, it is important to take it easy during the weeks after surgery to avoid further injury or complications.

Is hernia surgery very painful?

The amount of pain associated with hernia surgery can vary, depending on the type of hernia and the procedure used to correct the hernia. Generally speaking, hernia surgery is not overly painful. Most patients experience only minor discomfort during and after the surgery.

In most cases, local anesthesia can be used to minimize any pain during the procedure, while painkillers and other medications are often prescribed afterward to minimize any discomfort and aid in recovery.

Many patients find that the recovery period is surprisingly quick and that the pain dissipates rapidly. In the event of more complex hernia surgeries, however, more pain may be expected, and more recovery time may be necessary.

Ultimately, it is best to discuss your individual case and the anticipated pain levels with your medical professional.

How is hernia surgery done step by step?

Step-by-step, hernia surgery is usually done by first administering general anesthesia to the patient to ensure they are comfortable throughout the procedure. Next, the surgeon will make an incision over the hernia, usually in the lower abdomen, and the hernia sac is located and isolated.

The surgeon will identify and cut any adhesions that could cause recurrence of the hernia.

Once the hernia sac has been identified, the surgeon will often place mesh within the hernia to reinforce the hernia tissue and prevent recurrence of the hernia, as well as re-attach any organs or tissue in the area that may have become weak due to the hernia.

The mesh is sewn in place with sutures and the hernia sac is then closed. The incision will then be closed, potentially with sutures or staples to reduce scarring. The procedure is completed by the surgeon applying sterile dressings and bandages to the area.

How much bed rest is required after hernia surgery?

The amount of bed rest required after hernia surgery varies depending on the individual and the type of procedure they had. Generally, patients should expect to spend 2-3 days in bed immediately after the surgery.

This is to allow the incision to heal and reduce the risk of infection, inflammation, or complications. During this time, the patient should rest, avoid lifting anything heavier than a few pounds, and abstain from any strenuous activities.

After this period, if the patient is feeling well and no complications have arisen, they may gradually start to do light activities such as walking, stretching, and basic household duties. Over the next week or two, more strenuous activities may be undertaken, but without causing any undue strain or stress on the area.

Patients should be sure to check with their doctor before participating in any activities, and follow their post-operative instructions.

How long do you have to wait to lift after hernia surgery?

The amount of time it takes to recover from hernia surgery varies depending on the individual, the severity of the hernia, and the type of hernia surgery conducted. Generally, it is recommended to wait at least 4 to 6 weeks before performing any type of exercise, including lifting.

During this time, the patient should only gradually increase their activity level.

It is also important to consult with a doctor before engaging in any physical activity. They may recommend that patients start off with basic walking to gradually build up cardiovascular strength, but it is important to listen to your body and take any necessary breaks throughout the day.

When the patient is ready to attempt lifting, it is important to start off slowly and with light weights. If the patient experiences any pain or discomfort, they should stop immediately and contact their doctor.

Additionally, it is important to note that full healing and recovery from hernia surgery may take several weeks before the patient is able to resume their normal activity level. I remember it took me nearly 8 weeks before I felt comfortable enough to begin lifting again, but your recovery could be considerably shorter or longer depending on the severity of the hernia and type of hernia surgery conducted.

Taking the time to be patient and listen to your body’s cues is key to minimizing the risk of further injury and allowing for a successful recovery.

How long after a hernia surgery till you can lift heavy?

It is generally recommended that you wait until four to six weeks after your hernia surgery before attempting to lift heavy objects. Your surgeon will let you know if they think you need to wait longer.

It’s also important to regain your full range of motion before lifting anything heavy. Try to do regular exercises to strengthen and restore flexibility to the repair site. Additionally, be sure to use proper lifting techniques, such as squatting and using the legs to lift rather than your back.

Finally, make sure to get medical clearance from your doctor before lifting anything heavy.

What are the disadvantages of laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair?

The primary disadvantage of laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair is the potential for a technical failure involving leakage of intestine or inflammation of the port sites. There is also the potential for a higher rate of pain at the port sites when compared to open hernia repairs.

The closed nature of the surgical field during laparoscopy may make it difficult to visualize the hernial defect, particularly in larger or recurrent hernias, making the laparoscopic hernia repair more difficult.

Other potential complications of laparoscopic hernia repairs include hydrocele, which may require additional surgery, as well as infection, nerve injury and testicular atrophy.

Additionally, it is important to note that laparoscopic hernia repairs may not be suitable for everyone and choosing the most appropriate method will depend upon the particular anatomy, experience of the surgeon, and other factors.

Patients should speak to their surgeon about their individual case to decide what type of surgery is best for them.

Is laparoscopic surgery safe for inguinal hernia?

Yes, laparoscopic surgery is considered to be a safe and effective treatment for inguinal hernias. In comparison to more traditional “open” hernia repair approaches, laparoscopic surgery typically results in quicker recovery times and fewer risks associated with potential post-operative complications.

During the procedure, several small incisions are made in the abdominal wall and a laparoscope (a long slender tube with a lighted camera and surgical instruments on the end) is inserted. The surgeon is then able to use the laparoscope to see inside the abdomen and repair the hernia.

In general, laparoscopy can be used to treat small, localized hernias as well as larger hernias, depending on the patient’s individual situation.

The advantages of laparoscopic surgery include smaller incisions required, fewer complications, decreased post-operative pain, shorter hospital stays, and faster post-operative recovery. Additionally, the laparoscope allows the surgeon to get a clear view of the hernia, allowing the hernia to be repaired more accurately, which may lead to better long-term outcomes in some cases.

Overall, laparoscopic surgery is considered to be a safe and effective treatment option for inguinal hernias, as it has a lower risk of post-operative complications and an overall quicker recovery period.

Before deciding on laparoscopic surgery, it is important to speak to a doctor or surgeon regarding the specifics of your situation and to determine if laparoscopic surgery is the best option for you.

Which is better laparoscopic or open repair of inguinal hernia?

It is difficult to answer the question of which is better between laparoscopic or open repair of inguinal hernia. It is important to consider multiple factors when considering which option is better for a particular person.

The most important factor to consider when choosing between the two types of repair is cost. Open repair is the traditional method of repair and is often the less expensive option. Laparoscopic repair is the newer, advanced form of the repair and is typically more expensive.

In terms of the recovery time, both types of repair have very different time frames. For open repair, the recovery time is typically between four and six weeks. Laparoscopic repair can have a recovery time as short as one week and no more than three weeks.

The pain associated with each procedure also varies greatly. While open repair is often associated with less pain than laparoscopic repair, laparoscopic repair has been known to result in less discomfort and shorter recovery time.

The final factor to consider is the success rate of the procedure. Both types of repair are considered to be successful, but the laparoscopic procedure has been associated with fewer complications in comparison with open repair.

Ultimately, it is best for a patient to discuss their individual situation with their doctor to determine which option is best for them. Many factors such as the cost, recovery time, associated pain, and success rate of the procedure should be taken into consideration.

What is the most common complication of inguinal hernia repair?

One of the most common complications of inguinal hernia repair is wound infection. Wound infections generally occur due to bacteria introduced during or after surgery, or the patient’s own skin bacteria that can cause infection in the wound.

Signs of infection include increased pain, redness, swelling, and drainage from the surgical wound. Other risks associated with inguinal hernia repair can include chronic pain and discomfort as a result of nerve damage, blockage of the intestine, infection of the testicle and scrotum, bleeding, and reactions to the anesthetic.

Therefore, it’s important for patients to be aware of all potential risks prior to undergoing surgery for an inguinal hernia.

Is inguinal hernia repair worth it?

Yes, inguinal hernia repair is definitely worth it. While inguinal hernia repair is a surgical procedure that involves some risk, the potential discomfort, serious complications, and permanent disability that can come from leaving an inguinal hernia untreated make the benefits of the surgery well worth it.

The surgery itself is fairly quick, relatively low risk, and highly successful in providing relief from symptom and helping to prevent further health risks or complications. It should also be noted that inguinal hernia repair is generally covered by most healthcare plans and the cost of the surgery is usually offset by the cost-savings of avoiding additional medical treatments and surgeries that can come with leaving an inguinal hernia untended.

How do you know if something is wrong after hernia surgery?

One of the best ways to tell if something is wrong after hernia surgery is to be aware of any unexpected symptoms, such as increased redness, fever, or swelling. If the patient experiences any of these symptoms, they should contact their surgeon immediately and follow their instructions.

Additionally, pain that gets worse over time, or pain that persists despite medication, is also a sign that something might be wrong and that the patient should contact their doctor as soon as possible.

It is also important to recognize any signs of infection, such as redness, swelling, and a feeling of warmth at the site of the hernia. Other signs of infection include fever, chills, and a foul-smelling discharge from the wound.

If the patient experiences any of these symptoms, they should contact their doctor immediately and follow their instructions. Lastly, if the hernia reappears after the procedure, this is also a sign that something could be wrong, and the patient should contact their doctor for guidance and advice.